How does one provide a response to an unreasonable request? An answer to a question that shouldn’t have been asked in the first place. How does one reason with a monster?
The Tale of a Niggun opens on the eve of Purim, a significant Jewish holiday. Within the harrowing backdrop of Nazi-controlled ghettos, tension simmers as the Jewish community faces an ultimatum: surrender ten individuals for execution within twenty-four hours. This grim demand, intended as a twisted homage to the ten sons of Haman, a villainous figure from the Purim narrative, mirrors the genocidal intentions of the Nazis. Haman, an antagonist in Jewish folklore, similarly sought the annihilation of the Jewish people, albeit in the context of the ancient Persian Empire. Thus, the echoes of historical oppression reverberate ominously through the narrative, underscoring the gravity of the situation faced by the Jewish leaders.
The Purim story commemorates the courageous actions of Queen Esther, a Jewish woman who played a pivotal role in thwarting Haman's diabolical scheme to exterminate the Jewish population of Persia. Upon discovering Haman's genocidal plot, Esther fearlessly approached the king and implored him to intervene, thereby putting an end to Haman's nefarious intentions. Esther's bravery and diplomacy are celebrated as instrumental in saving her people from imminent destruction, making her a revered figure in Jewish tradition and an enduring symbol of resilience and courage.
The Jewish leaders faced a grave dilemma as they grappled with the Nazis' ultimatum to surrender ten Jews from the ghetto to be hanged. Seeking guidance and wisdom, they turned to the resident ghetto rabbi for counsel. Should they comply with the Nazis' demand and sacrifice their own people to save the rest, or should they refuse and risk facing the wrath of the oppressors? The decision weighed heavily on their shoulders, reflecting the agonizing moral choices forced upon them by the brutality of the Nazi regime.
Similar to the Jewish leaders, the rabbi finds himself unwilling to bear the burden of such a dire decision. However, recognizing his role as their spiritual guide, he reluctantly shoulders their weighty burden. Instructing them to give him space for reflection and meditation, the rabbi retreats to contemplate the weighty implications of the Nazis' ultimatum.
Throughout the night, the rabbi seeks guidance from the spirits of legendary rabbis from centuries past, hoping to glean wisdom on how to navigate the Nazis' demands. However, one by one, each guide fails to provide a satisfactory answer, leaving the rabbi grappling with the weight of the decision alone.
As the ghetto rabbi reflects and seeks guidance from the teachings of ancient rabbis, he is reminded of the unbreakable bond within the Jewish community. He realizes that his role as a rabbi is not to face challenges alone, but to stand alongside his fellow Jews, sharing in both their joy and their pain.
Through his deep contemplation and scholarly pursuits, the rabbi recalls the teachings of the Baal Shem Tov, an influential figure in Jewish mysticism and the founder of Hasidism. He remembers the Baal Shem Tov's practice of invoking divine intervention through the power of sacred melodies, known as niggunim. Inspired by this tradition, the rabbi reaches a resolute decision by morning: no Jew will be surrendered to the Nazis. He affirms that the victims of their enemies shall not be regarded as their own.
Rather than yielding to the demands of the Nazis, the community chooses to enact the sacred song of the Baal Shem Tov, offering gratitude to the divine above. With heartfelt melodies and joyful movements, they sing and dance, a blend of celebration and lamentation. Their voices rise towards the heavens, reaching God's ears. Will he hear them?
A tale brimming with hope yet tinged with sorrow. It portrays the power of community at its finest, juxtaposed with humanity's darkest facets.
Elie Wiesel's powerful narrative once again exposes the dark depths of human wickedness, serving as a stark reminder of the lessons the world seems to be forgetting. As society edges closer to repeating past mistakes, Wiesel's work stands as a crucial warning against the erosion of humanity's collective memory.
Other books By Elie Wiesel that you might enjoy!
Other books that are similar to The Tale of a Niggun that you might enjoy!
Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, meaning I get a commission if you decide to make a purchase through my links, at no cost to you. Please read my disclosure for more info.
Other books By Mark Podwal that you might enjoy!
